Facebook Instagram
    Trending
    • From Freelancer to Digital Marketing Agency Owner: The Inspiring Journey of Gangesh Sameer Govekar
    • Happiness Activist, Susheel Agarwal, launches his book “Mastering Group Health Insurance” in The HR To CEO workshop
    • Transforming Lives Through First Transformational Tourism Technology Platform by 360 Explorer Inc. & Anand Bansode
    • Employee Transport Management: Why Track Carbon Emissions?
    • Real Action, Not Words Alone, Needed to Achieve UN Agenda 2030: Civil Society
    • Revolutionizing Security in India with Monitored Alarm Systems
    • NovelVox Earns “Best Digital CX Platform” Award at the 5th Annual India CX Summit & Awards 2023 in Mumbai
    • Chandigarh Girls will be conquering the Universe
    Facebook Instagram
    The Daily BeatThe Daily Beat
    Advertise
    • Home
    • National
    • Global
    • Politics
    • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
    • Brandstudio
    The Daily BeatThe Daily Beat
    Home»National»Is SC a divided house on judicial interference in pandemic management? | India News
    National

    Is SC a divided house on judicial interference in pandemic management? | India News

    Web AdminBy Web AdminJuly 15, 20213 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Telegram Pinterest LinkedIn Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter Telegram WhatsApp

    [ad_1]

    NEW DELHI: Just a day after Supreme Court judge DY Chandrachud took some credit in the court bringing about a revision in the Centre’s vaccination policy, a bench of Supreme Court on Wednesday observed that constitutional courts should be restrained in policy decisions and even said it will consider setting out norms.
    Hearing a plea filed by Uttar Pradesh government against the Allahabad high court which had passed a slew of directions on management of the pandemic in the state and passed adverse observations against the government, a bench of Justices Vineet Saran and Dinesh Maheshwari asked whether the HC should have entered the arena.
    The bench said the intention of the court could not be questioned and there was no doubt it wanted to improve the situation but the issue was whether interference was at all needed during the period of crisis which should be left to be handled by government and experts. The SC bench’s views come in the wake of the court and several high courts taking up issues like oxygen supply and vaccination.
    “Howsoever good (is the) intention and objective, when there is demarcation, then we have to respect the demarcation. We have to be very careful..,” the bench said, referring that the judiciary should not interfere in the domain of the executive as per the principles of separation of power.
    “Everybody needs to be conscious about what is to be done by whom. How far the constitutional court goes into such matter. We want to lay down on that aspect,” it said.
    The difference of opinion among different SC benches on various issues, including the pandemic, showed up with Justice Chandrachud on Monday saying the state is empowered to take policy decisions on the pandemic but if this infringes on the constitutional rights of the people, the validity of the policy is amenable to judicial review. However, since the Indian Supreme Court sits in smaller and co-equal benches, it gives way to contestations about the interpretation of same socio-economic rights and the level of deference that is shown to the executive on issues of policy, he said.
    He also cited that a bench of the SC refused to entertain a PIL for payment of minimum wages for migrant workers during lock down but another bench took suo motu cognisance and passed directions. “While the above examples show how the Supreme Court differed in its approach to intervene in the actions…it also indicates how smaller and co-equal benches of the Court provide a possibility of reading law differently,” he said.



    [ad_2]

    Source

    Allahabad High Court Breaking news divided DY Chandrachud Google news house India India news India news today interference judicial Management news Pandemic PIL SC supreme court The Daily Beat Today news Trending uttar pradesh government vaccination policy
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest WhatsApp Telegram
    Web Admin
    • Website

    Related Posts

    VehicleCare: Pioneering the Future of EV Maintenance and Repair in India

    The PM Modi-inspired Fit India Movement’s Young Ambassador trained 50,000 students in Karate.

    Author Dr. Pradeep Kumar Yadav bestowed with prestigious Atal National Award (In remembrance of Honorable Former Prime-Minister Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayjee) for the unity and integrity to make one nation through non-profit and inexhaustible Karate contributions to the country. 

    Nelson Mandela Nobel Peace Award 2022 conferred to Author Dr. Pradeep Kumar Yadav for Karate contributions to the country.

    FIVE WRITERS OF INDIA YOU MUST DEFINITELY KNOW ARE JOHN GIFTAH, MAYURI KADAMBANDE, SNEHA JAIN, PARTHSINGH RAJPUT AND SHAIVYA KAPOOR

    Rajya Sabha Officer & Author Dr. Pradeep Kumar Yadav Conferred The Atal National Award By The Governor Shri Bhagat Singh Koshyari At Raj Bhawan, Mumbai.

    For All The Trending News Updates from Bollywood & Pollywood Film Industry, Television and OTT, Movie Reviews, Celebrity Biographies Visit Filmi Bytes

    From Freelancer to Digital Marketing Agency Owner: The Inspiring Journey of Gangesh Sameer Govekar

    September 30, 2023

    Happiness Activist, Susheel Agarwal, launches his book “Mastering Group Health Insurance” in The HR To CEO workshop

    September 28, 2023

    Transforming Lives Through First Transformational Tourism Technology Platform by 360 Explorer Inc. & Anand Bansode

    September 27, 2023

    Employee Transport Management: Why Track Carbon Emissions?

    September 25, 2023

    Real Action, Not Words Alone, Needed to Achieve UN Agenda 2030: Civil Society

    September 25, 2023

    Revolutionizing Security in India with Monitored Alarm Systems

    September 21, 2023

    NovelVox Earns “Best Digital CX Platform” Award at the 5th Annual India CX Summit & Awards 2023 in Mumbai

    September 19, 2023

    Chandigarh Girls will be conquering the Universe

    September 18, 2023
    The Daily Beat
    • About
    • Contact
    • Advertisement
    © 2023 The Daily Beat. All Rights Reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.